1380.31 – Find the falsehood


Suppose hh, mm and kk are integers and h<m<k<0h < m < k < 0. Which of these statements is false?

  1. mk<hkmk < hk,
  2. mh<kmmh < km,
  3. h+k<m+kh + k < m + k,
  4. 0<kh0 < k - h.

Solution

Solution. We are given that h<m<k<0h < m < k < 0 and four statements. We could simply pick negative values for hh, mm, and kk and check the four statements. But, if we like, we can use fancy reasoning. Have a look:

(a) mk<hkmk < hk,

Let’s cancel kk, which we are allowed to do because kk is not zero. But kk is negative, so the cancellation switches the direction of the inequality. We get m>hm > h. This we were given. This one is true.

(b) mh<kmmh < km,

Again let’s cancel the common factor (mm) and switch the direction of the inequality. We get h>kh > k. Whoa Nellie! We were given h<kh < k. This must be the false one.

(c) h+k<m+kh + k < m + k,

Here we may subtract the common addend (kk). This does not require we switch the direction of the inequality. We get h<mh < m which we were given. This one is true.

(d) 0<kh0 < k - h.

Add hh to both sides and we get h<kh < k, which we were given. This one is true.